Theft Calculator Usage and Suitability Assessment

  • 1
    Issue Review
  • 2
    Issue Conclusion
  • 3
    Issue Closed
Step 3 of 3
Issue Closed
Summary
Currently, it is uncertain how widely the existing Theft Assessment Calculators are being used by Parties for assessing energy losses due to theft, despite Schedules 7 & 8 mandating the usage. There is evidence to suggest inconsistent application across Parties, and whilst there has only been one derogation request, anecdotal feedback indicates that other Parties are also struggling to use the calculator.

Latest update and next planned activity

Date of latest update
Latest Update
30/10/2026 - A Closure Report has now been published, and this Issue has now been classed as resolved. A final working group will be hosted on 18 November to inform Parties of the solution requirements developed and the next steps planned for the Theft Assessment Calculator.

Impacts Overview

Impacted Consumers
Non-Domestic Domestic
Impacted REC Parties and Market Participants
Energy Supplier (ES)
Impacted REC Documents
Schedule 7 - Energy Theft Reduction Standards Definition Document Data Item Catalogue Market Message Catalogue
Priority and rationale
Standard

Solution development

Problem Statement
The current lack of clarity around the usage, effectiveness, and suitability of the energy theft calculator is leading to inconsistent assessments and reporting across the industry. This ambiguity hinders the identification and sharing of best practices, creates an uneven playing field among Parties, and may result in inconsistent outcomes for consumers. Additionally, it limits the tool’s potential to support robust, court-ready evidence ahead of the Energy Theft Unit (ETU) and Referral Assessment Service (RAS) launch. A lack of transparency may also discourage Parties from raising concerns, further impeding improvement and compliance.
Proposed solution summary
  1. It is expected that there will be a collaborative information gathering exercise to thoroughly assess the current Theft Calculator. This includes collecting data on specific use cases, frequency of use, and devices (such as laptops or mobile devices), evaluating whether its current functionalities align with industry needs for assessing energy theft and TDIS submissions, and reviewing the suitability of its current platform to identify preferred future delivery mechanisms (e.g. web or app-based). This approach aims to inform potential enhancements or a comprehensive upgrade, ensuring a consistent and reliable tool that can be accessed and used effectively across multiple operational scenarios and devices for the benefit of all Parties.

There is currently no Change Plan.

Original submission

Change details

Aiyesha Andrade - RECCo
15 Jul 2025

Change details

Theft Calculator Usage and Suitability Assessment
Currently, it is uncertain how widely the existing Theft Assessment Calculators are being used by Parties for assessing energy losses due to theft, despite Schedules 7 & 8 mandating the usage. There is evidence to suggest inconsistent application across Parties, and whilst there has only been one derogation request, anecdotal feedback indicates that other Parties are also struggling to use the calculator. It is also unclear whether it is consistently applied for Theft Detection Incentive Scheme (TDIS) submissions, or if its current platform is fit for purpose across all operational environments.
Gaining a comprehensive understanding of its current usage and effectiveness is crucial to determine if the calculator is delivering its intended purpose efficiently and consistently across the industry.
The lack of clarity on the calculator's usage and suitability may be impacting the industry in several ways:

1. Inconsistency in assessments - Without understanding current usage patterns and effectiveness, there is a risk of inconsistencies in how energy theft is assessed and subsequently reported in TDIS.

2. Best Practice sharing - It prevents the identification and sharing of best practices related to energy theft assessment, limiting opportunities for collective improvement and efficiency.

3. Uneven playing field - An unclear understanding of the tool's performance across various platforms and user scenarios can lead to an uneven playing field among Parties in their approach to energy theft.

4. Future preparedness - Without this foundational data, it is challenging to ensure the calculator can provide robust, consistent, and potentially court-ready evidence, which will be increasingly important with the impending establishment of the Energy Theft Unit (ETU) and Referral Assessment Service RAS).

5. Customer detriment - Whether a customer is charged for stolen energy may vary from Supplier to Supplier, potentially leading to inconsistent outcomes for consumers.

6. Reluctance to report issues - Parties may be failing to raise their issues or concerns with the tool due to fear of being put under the spotlight or highlighting potential REC Schedule breaches.
It is expected that there will be a collaborative information gathering exercise to thoroughly assess the current Theft Calculator. This includes collecting data on specific use cases, frequency of use, and devices (such as laptops or mobile devices), evaluating whether its current functionalities align with industry needs for assessing energy theft and TDIS submissions, and reviewing the suitability of its current platform to identify preferred future delivery mechanisms (e.g. web or app-based). This approach aims to inform potential enhancements or a comprehensive upgrade, ensuring a consistent and reliable tool that can be accessed and used effectively across multiple operational scenarios and devices for the benefit of all Parties.
The main reason this issue is being explored is due to a current live derogation related to the lack of functionality of the new device with the existing theft calculator. Beyond this, this issue is set against the backdrop of ongoing industry discussions about the future of energy theft management and the establishment of a dedicated Energy Theft Unit. Providing robust, consistent, and legally defensible data is crucial for the unit's success and for effective energy theft prosecution.

Previous discussions with Parties have highlighted diverse experiences and limitations with the current calculator, especially concerning platform accessibility. These have contributed to inconsistent approaches to assessing losses, which ultimately impacts the accuracy and reliability of the Theft Estimation Methodology (TEM) and in turn the annual cost of energy theft to every household.
While a "quick fix" was proposed to address an immediate need, it was deemed potentially detrimental to industry-wide efficiency and consistency. This REC Issue aims to gather the foundational data needed to inform any future development or comprehensive overhaul of the theft assessment calculators. This ensures any investment creates a level playing field and a tool that supports best practices and consistency in TDIS and RAS assessments for all Parties.

Impacts

All
Safety, Trust and confidence
-
Schedule 7 - Energy Theft Reduction, Schedule 8 - Unbilled Energy Code of Practice
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No
No details provided

Priority & timing

No
-
Development: Intention to have a refined solution to be assessed by industry prior to September 2025.

Implementation: September 2026
-
No details provided
Safety, Trust and confidence

Activity

Change Report - Initial Assessment and Change Plan Report has been updated to I0265 Change Report.pdf.
Status has been changed to Issue Review.
maxime.van-eyseren, vaishnsharma have been allocated as SME.