Amendments to Sample Access Agreement
Summary
A number of Non-Party REC Service Users have entered into an Access Agreement with RECCo under the Code’s Qualification and Maintenance Schedule, to obtain access to the CSS and become a CSS User. These Access Agreements are based on the Sample Access Agreement appended to Schedule 9 to the Code, which DCC believes should have been revised to address issues they have identified.
Latest update and next planned activity
Date of latest update
Latest Update
08/11/2024 - This Change Proposal has been implemented as part of the November 2024 REC Release.
Impacts Overview
Impacted REC Parties and Market Participants
Other (Other)
Impacted REC Documents
Schedule 9 - Qualification and Maintenance
Priority and rationale
Standard
Solution development
Problem Statement
The CRS Provider has raised that the Sample Access Agreement appended to Schedule 9 – Qualification and Maintenance does not provide adequate protections to Non-Party REC Service Users or the CRS Provider regarding liabilities or data security.
Proposed solution summary
- As a Consumer, I want systems containing my information to be correctly assured, so that my personal information is kept safe and services I expect to be able to use are not disrupted.
- As a Non-Party REC Service User, I want the Access Agreement I sign before I can access services from the CRS Provider to give me the same protections as other service users, so I am protected from loss and liability caused by another service user, or the service itself.
- As the CRS Provider, I want Non-Party REC Service Users to be held to the same provisions as other CSS Users, so I am protected from loss and liability caused by them.
- As a CSS User, I want Non-Party REC Service Users to be held to the same
Solution documents
Documents Library
Change Plan
PARTY IMPACT ASSESSMENT
Completed
Start:
02 Sep 2022Due:
24 May 2024Completion:
24 May 2024PRELIMINARY CHANGE REPORT ISSUED
Completed
Start:
24 May 2024Due:
18 Jul 2024Completion:
18 Jul 2024RESPONSIBLE COMMITTEE REVIEW
Completed
Start:
18 Jul 2024Due:
30 Jul 2024Completion:
30 Jul 2024CONSULTATION ISSUED
Completed
Start:
30 Jul 2024Due:
02 Aug 2024Completion:
01 Aug 2024FINAL CHANGE REPORT ISSUED
Completed
Start:
02 Aug 2024Due:
12 Sep 2024Completion:
12 Sep 2024RESPONSIBLE COMMITTEE DECISION
Completed
Start:
12 Sep 2024Due:
24 Sep 2024Completion:
24 Sep 2024Original submission
Change details
Cordelia Grey - DCC
2 Sep 2022
Change details
Amendments to Sample Access Agreement appended to the Qualification and Maintenance Schedule 9 to the Code
A number of Non-Party REC Service Users have entered into an Access Agreement with RECCo under the Code’s Qualification and Maintenance Schedule to obtain access to the CSS and become a CSS User. These Access Agreements are based on the Sample Access Agreement appended to Schedule 9 to the Code, which DCC believes should have been revised to address the following issues:
(1) under Clause 3.1 of the Access Agreement the User is granted rights associated with being a CSS User subject to and in accordance with, and agrees to be bound by and to comply with, the Central Switching Service Schedule and the Switching Data Management Schedule only whereas the Switching Service Management Schedule (Schedule 26 to the Code) is also mandatory for CSS Users;
(2) while the provisions of Clause 19 (REC Controller Obligations) of the Code (as implemented under Change Proposal R0046A);
(3) Clause 13 (Third Party Rights) of the Access Agreement fails to include the CRS Provider (and Green Deal Provider) so it has no contractual enforcement rights against the User whereas, by virtue of Clause 26.12(c) (Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999) of the Code, the User shall be entitled to enforce directly against the CRS Provider (and Green Deal Provider) its rights under the REC Schedules with which it has agreed to comply in its Access Agreement, plus various rights under the Code.
(1) under Clause 3.1 of the Access Agreement the User is granted rights associated with being a CSS User subject to and in accordance with, and agrees to be bound by and to comply with, the Central Switching Service Schedule and the Switching Data Management Schedule only whereas the Switching Service Management Schedule (Schedule 26 to the Code) is also mandatory for CSS Users;
(2) while the provisions of Clause 19 (REC Controller Obligations) of the Code (as implemented under Change Proposal R0046A);
(3) Clause 13 (Third Party Rights) of the Access Agreement fails to include the CRS Provider (and Green Deal Provider) so it has no contractual enforcement rights against the User whereas, by virtue of Clause 26.12(c) (Contracts (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999) of the Code, the User shall be entitled to enforce directly against the CRS Provider (and Green Deal Provider) its rights under the REC Schedules with which it has agreed to comply in its Access Agreement, plus various rights under the Code.
(1) The omission of the Switching Service Management Schedule from Clause 3.1 of the Access Agreement is likely an oversight. While it is unlikely that a Non-Party REC Service User who enters into an Access Agreement to become a CSS User will be denied the rights available under Schedule 26 to the Code, the User will not be contractually bound by the undertakings set out in the Service Management Schedule. This risks the CRS Provider and other Market Participants suffering loss or incurring liability to other parties if the User were to breach these obligations.
(2) Because the provisions of Clause 20 (REC Processor Obligations) do not apply on an Equivalent Basis if a User acts as a REC Processor of REC Data Processed on behalf of a REC Party who is a controller of the REC Data, those entities must enter into separate bilateral data processing agreements. This is administratively burdensome and creates a risk of inconsistency and unfairness of the terms that govern the processing of REC Data whereas, under R0046A, RECCo was seeking to improve its ability to maintain a comprehensive approach to the governance of personal data under, and achieve the objectives of, the Code. It also risks REC Controllers and Users breaching Data Protection Legislation.
(3) The omission of the CRS Provider from Clause 13 of the Access Agreement means that it would have no contractual remedies if it were to suffer loss or incur liability to other parties caused by a Non-Party REC Service User who breaches its obligations under an Access Agreement to access the CSS. There is a similar impact for Green Deal Providers if a User were to breach its obligations under the Green Deal Arrangements Schedule 18 to the Code.
(2) Because the provisions of Clause 20 (REC Processor Obligations) do not apply on an Equivalent Basis if a User acts as a REC Processor of REC Data Processed on behalf of a REC Party who is a controller of the REC Data, those entities must enter into separate bilateral data processing agreements. This is administratively burdensome and creates a risk of inconsistency and unfairness of the terms that govern the processing of REC Data whereas, under R0046A, RECCo was seeking to improve its ability to maintain a comprehensive approach to the governance of personal data under, and achieve the objectives of, the Code. It also risks REC Controllers and Users breaching Data Protection Legislation.
(3) The omission of the CRS Provider from Clause 13 of the Access Agreement means that it would have no contractual remedies if it were to suffer loss or incur liability to other parties caused by a Non-Party REC Service User who breaches its obligations under an Access Agreement to access the CSS. There is a similar impact for Green Deal Providers if a User were to breach its obligations under the Green Deal Arrangements Schedule 18 to the Code.
Amend the sample Access Agreement as proposed in the attached mark-up to address the above issues.
DCC has prepared this Change Proposal after raising the concerns addressed at (2) and (3) above in response to CP R0046A, to which the Code Manager responded that they were out of scope for that Change Proposal and would require a separate Change Proposal.
Impacts
Electricity, Gas, Domestic Prepayment, Domestic Credit, Microbusiness, Small and Medium Enterprise (SME)
Switching experience, Trust and confidence
-
Schedule 9 - Qualification and Maintenance
The Sample Access Agreement is set out in Appendix 1 to the Qualification and Maintenance Schedule.
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
Central Switching Service (CSS), CSS Certificate Authority, Switching Operator
-
DCC, Green Deal Providers
CSS Users
No details provided
-
No
No details provided
Priority & timing
No
This Change Proposal meets the Urgency criteria (a) and (c) under Ofgem Guidance on Code Modification Urgency Criteria.
RECCo has entered into a number of Access Agreements with CSS Users that omit the drafting described in this Change Proposal. This potentially risks:
(1) REC Controllers and Users breaching Data Protection legislation because Users are not bound by Clause 20 (REC Processor Obligations) of the Code which clarifies how REC Controllers and REC Processors could meet their data protections obligations in the support of a functioning retail energy market; and
(2) A significant commercial impact on Users, Market Participants, and the CRS Provider as a result of suffering their own losses and incurring liability to third parties. This is compounded by the CRS Provider having no reciprocal contractual enforcement rights under Clause 13 of the access agreement.
RECCo has entered into a number of Access Agreements with CSS Users that omit the drafting described in this Change Proposal. This potentially risks:
(1) REC Controllers and Users breaching Data Protection legislation because Users are not bound by Clause 20 (REC Processor Obligations) of the Code which clarifies how REC Controllers and REC Processors could meet their data protections obligations in the support of a functioning retail energy market; and
(2) A significant commercial impact on Users, Market Participants, and the CRS Provider as a result of suffering their own losses and incurring liability to third parties. This is compounded by the CRS Provider having no reciprocal contractual enforcement rights under Clause 13 of the access agreement.
DCC would suggest the amendments to the REC Sample Access Agreement be progressed under an Urgent timetable.
No
No details provided
-