Clarifying requirement for continuous billing following an Erroneous Switch

  • 1
    Withdrawn
Step 1 of 1
Withdrawn
Summary
Schedule 30 (Resolution of Consumer Facing Switching and Billing Issues) includes requirements on Suppliers relating to the identification and resolution of Erroneous Switches. This includes a set of principles and outcomes that Supplier's must adhere to. One of the required outcomes of an Erroneous Switch is that the consumer is only billed once for the period of the Erroneous Switch, and that they are only billed by the Supplier they have a valid contract with. Paragraph 5.2 of the CFSB Schedule sets out that the Losing Supplier should accept responsibility for billing during the period of the Erroneous Switch. However, it is not explicitly clear that the Gaining Supplier should not bill the consumer for consumption during the period of the erroneous supply. This Change Proposal has been raised to review the wording of paragraph 5.2, or the resolution outcomes more generally, so there it is clear to Suppliers, and the REC PAB in their assurance activities, what the expectations are.

Latest update and next planned activity

Date of latest update
Latest Update
04/10/2023 - Following the approval of R0138, this change has been withdrawn.

Impacts Overview

Solution development

There is currently no Change Plan.

Original submission

Change details

Jon Hawkins - RECCo
31 Mar 2023

Change details

Clarifying requirement for continuous billing following an Erroneous Switch
Schedule 30 (Resolution of Consumer Facing Switching and Billing Issues) includes requirements on Suppliers relating to the identification and resolution of Erroneous Switches. This includes a set of principles and outcomes that Supplier's must adhere to. One of the required outcomes of an Erroneous Switch is that the consumer is only billed once for the period of the Erroneous Switch, and that they are only billed by the Supplier they have a valid contract with. In the case of an Erroneous Switch, this means that the Supplier that erroneously gained the supply would be expected to not bill the consumer for any consumption during that period (and return any payment previously recovered from the consumer) and the Supplier that erroneously lost the supply would bill the consumer for that period under the terms of the original contract. This requirement was previously set out more explicitly in the MRA, however, it is not explicitly clear in the current drafting of the CFSB Schedule. Paragraph 5.2 says: "If the Gaining Supplier identifies that an Erroneous Switch has occurred for a Consumer that the Losing Supplier has already re-registered or is in the process of re-registering, the Erroneous Switch request takes precedence. This means that a Losing Supplier cannot reject an Erroneous Switch request if they are already in the process of re-registering. In this situation, the Losing Supplier shall accept responsibility for billing during the period that the Consumer was being supplied by the Gaining Supplier, although the decision on whether to bill the Consumer for any energy taken over this period will remain at the discretion of the Losing Supplier." This clarifies that the Losing Supplier should accept responsibility for billing during the period of the Erroneous Switch. However, it is not explicitly clear that the Gaining Supplier should not bill the consumer for consumption during the period of the erroneous supply. We believe the wording of paragraph 5.2, or the resolution outcomes more generally, could be made clearer so there it is clear to Suppliers, and the REC PAB in their assurance activities, what the expectations are.
No reported impact at the moment, but this could cause issues for consumers if Suppliers have different interpretations of this requirement in the future.
Clear, unambigous requirements set out in Schedule 30 that can be appropriately assured, measured and enforced, where required.
With the move to MHHS, Suppliers will also not be able to re-adjust consumption between each other by amending the Switch Meter Reading, therefore the obligation to ensure continuous billing with the consumer should be clear in the event this results in a financial disadvantage to the Gaining Supplier under MHHS.

Impacts

Electricity, Gas, Domestic Prepayment, Domestic Credit, Microbusiness, Small and Medium Enterprise (SME), Industrial and Commercial (I&C)
Switching experience, Billing accuracy
-
Schedule 30 - Resolution of Consumer Facing Switching and Billing Issues
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
Energy Suppliers
-
No details provided
-
No
No details provided

Priority & timing

Yes
-
No
No hard dependencies, but the obligation should be explicit and clear ahead of the introduction of MHHS as the new MHHS arrangements will mean the Gaining Supplier will be accept a financial disadvantage as a result of continuous billing, as they won't be able to adjust the settlement position.
No details provided
-

Activity