Erroneous Switch Review: Amendments to Clause 4.5

  • 1
    Initial Assessment
  • 2
    Solution Development
  • 3
    Consultation
  • 4
    Decision
  • 5
    Awaiting Implementation
  • 6
    Implemented
Step 2 of 6
Solution Development
Summary
Schedule 30, Section B, Clause 4.5 currently permits Energy Suppliers to raise an Erroneous Switch (ES) within 24 months of the suspected ES taking place. However, analysis from the I0237 Erroneous Switch Review shows that 98% of ESs are raised within the first 12 months.

Latest update and next planned activity

Date of latest update
Latest Update
30/10/2026 REC Change Panel voted to approve the Extension to Plan for R0313 via an ex-committee decision.

Impacts Overview

Priority and rationale
Standard

Solution development

Problem Statement
The existing 24‑month allowance no longer reflects operational practice and maintains an unnecessarily long resolution period that adds complexity and increases the potential for data quality issues, Consumer confusion, and prolonged operational uncertainty. When the original 24‑month time limit was introduced (prior to REC Go‑Live), it was expected that this would later be reduced to 12 months soon after implementation. However, this subsequent reduction did not take place.
Proposed solution summary
  1. Amend Schedule 30 – Resolution of Consumer Facing Switching and Billing Issues, Section B, Clause 4.5 to reduce the timeframe to 12 months and ensure Consumer contact is made in a reasonable timescales.

Workgroup

Has a Workgroup supported the development of the Change Proposal?
No

There is currently no Change Plan.

Original submission

Change details

James Hardy - REC Code Manager
13 Feb 2026

Change details

Erroneous Switch Review: Amendments to Clause 4.5
Schedule 30, Section B, Clause 4.5 currently permits Energy Suppliers to raise an Erroneous Switch (ES) within 24 months of the suspected ES taking place. However, analysis from the I0237 Erroneous Switch Review shows that 98% of ESs are raised within the first 12 months, and Energy Suppliers rarely, if ever, rely on the full 24-month window.

The existing 24‑month allowance no longer reflects operational practice and maintains an unnecessarily long resolution period that adds complexity and increases the potential for data quality issues, Consumer confusion, and prolonged operational uncertainty.

When the original 24‑month time limit was introduced (prior to REC Go‑Live), it was expected that this would later be reduced to 12 months soon after implementation. However, this subsequent reduction did not take place. The I0237 working group has since reviewed the position and, in agreement with the Code Manager, concluded that this change should now be implemented alongside the I0237 Erroneous Switch Review.
An unnecessarily long window to raise an Erroneous Switch process causes the following impacts:

• Creates misalignment between industry process and actual behaviour.
• Prolongs the timeframe in which Energy Suppliers must maintain monitoring and support for legacy registrations.
• Introduces an additional training burden for Energy Suppliers with extended operational overhead for exceptions that rarely occur.
• Causes uncertainty for Consumers, who may be contacted long after the Switch event, and negatively impacts the Consumer Switching experience.
• Adds complexity to reporting, as the current window is not reflective of real-world practice.
Amend Schedule 30 – Resolution of Consumer Facing Switching and Billing Issues, Section B, Clause 4.5 to:

“This Section B shall only be used in the period of 12 months following the suspected Erroneous Switch. Beyond this point, Energy Suppliers shall seek to agree bilaterally how to treat a potential Erroneous Switch. The Gaining Supplier shall write to the Consumer within 5 Working Days of identifying that an Erroneous Switch has occurred (including via bilateral discussions with the Losing Supplier) setting out:
(a) The Erroneous Switch process has commenced or;
(b) The reasons why the Erroneous Switch process cannot complete; and
(c) The Consumer’s rights to Switch to another Energy Supplier”

This aligns the Code with evidence‑based operational practice, reduces unnecessary process overhead, and simplifies Energy Supplier obligations.
The I0237 Erroneous Switch Review demonstrated that 98% of ETs are raised within 12 months, making the 24‑month period disproportionate.

Workgroup consensus reached that a reduction to 12 months offers efficiency gains without negatively impacting Consumers.

No negative operational, system or Consumer impacts were identified by the workgroup when discussing the shortening of the window. However, the Code Manager will still proceed with a Party impact assessment as part of the Change Process to review this expectation.

Impacts

All
Ability to pay, Billing accuracy, Switching experience, Trust and confidence
-
Schedule 30 - Resolution of Consumer Facing Switching and Billing Issues
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
Energy Suppliers
-
No details provided
-
No
No details provided

Priority & timing

Yes
-
Development: No later than the development of I0237 Solution.

Implementation: As soon as possible due to the impact on Consumer detriment, but no later than any implementation of any potential solutions proposed under I0237.
No
No details provided
Ability to pay, Billing accuracy, Switching experience, Trust and confidence

Activity

No one has been allocated as Lead Analyst.