Service Provider Performance Charges (DCC)

  • 1
    Initial Assessment
  • 2
    Solution Development
  • 3
    Consultation
  • 4
    Decision
  • 5
    Awaiting Implementation
  • 6
    Implemented
Step 6 of 6
Implemented
Summary
This Change Proposal seeks to introduce an economic incentive scheme for the Centralised Registration Service (CRS) Provider through the introduction of Service Provider Performance Charges linked to performance against service levels defined in the REC.

Latest update and next planned activity

Date of latest update
Latest Update
02/04/2023 - Change Proposal implemented 01 April 2023

Impacts Overview

Impacted Consumers
Others
Impacted REC Parties and Market Participants
Data and Communications Company (DCC)
Impacted REC Documents
Schedule 6 - Performance Assurance
Impacted REC Services
CSS Certificate Authority Central Switching Service (CSS)
Priority and rationale
High

Solution development

Problem Statement
Service Provider performance measures and charges do not currently exist for services that are not procured by the Retail Energy Code Company but are provided by other Parties. The performance of Service Providers is essential to the proper functioning of the market, without appropriate performance measure or Performance Charges there is little incentive for these providers to maintain service performance or improve poor performance in a timely manner.
Proposed solution summary
  1. As the REC Code Manager, I want to ensure that REC Service Providers achieve their Service Level Agreements (SLAs) defined in REC Service Definitions, so that impacts to the REC Code Manager, REC Parties and other Service Providers, as a consequence of Service Provider underperformance, are minimised and the change process delivers to time and cost.
  2. As a Service Provider, I want clarity on when and how Performance Charges will be used as part of the Performance Assurance Techniques, so that I’m clear on what service levels I need to meet and the consequences of not delivering against these.
Solution documents
R0025 Final Legal Text 05 Jun 2026 ZIP - 144.44 KB
05 Jun 2026
Change Plan

Preliminary Change Report and Consultation Issued

Completed

Start:

04 Jan 2022

Due:

15 Nov 2022

Completion:

15 Nov 2022

Final Change Report Issued

Completed

Start:

15 Nov 2022

Due:

09 Dec 2022

Completion:

09 Dec 2022

Responsible Committee Decision

Completed

Start:

09 Dec 2022

Due:

20 Dec 2022

Completion:

20 Dec 2022

Send to Authority for Decision

Completed

Start:

20 Dec 2022

Due:

21 Dec 2022

Completion:

21 Dec 2022

Original submission

Change details

- - REC Code Manager
4 Jan 2022

Change details

Service Provider Performance Charges (ERDS, GRDS, DCC)
The performance of REC Service Providers is essential to the proper functioning of the market. In particular, underperformance related to Service Level Agreements (SLAs) through agreed service definitions and also underperformance related to change requests, including the timeliness of impact assessments and the timeliness of changes being made by planned release dates, have been identified as key areas that would benefit from incentivising performance.

There are two categories of service providers under REC governance, those procured by RECCo and those provided by other Parties. RECCo are responsible for contract management, including creating appropriate service levels and service credits for the services they procure. However, similar incentives do not exist for services outside of RECCo’s control. This is why the proposed Performance Charge would only apply to Service Providers not procured by RECCo. This includes the Central Switching Service (CSS), CSS Certificate Authority, Switching Operator, Gas Retail Data Service (GRDS) and Electricity Retail Data Service (EDRS).
Service Providers not meeting their respective SLAs, particularly relating to user support, response times and service availability, can have consequential impacts on the wider market. An incentive-based performance regime can therefore be used to encourage REC Service Providers to be responsive to the needs of its users and deliver good consumer outcomes in line with their service deifnitions.

In relation to Service Provider change request performance, the Code Manager’s ability to deliver changes in accordance with the approved Change timetable will be compromised if Service Providers are delayed in providing impact assessments. This may result in changes being delayed and/or proceeding without proper impact assessment.

Subject to changes being implemented, delays to a release can have impacts on market participants, other Service Providers, the Code Manager and/or other industry Codes. For example, all these organisations might have prepared themselves to go-live on the release date and then subsequently have to back out their changes if the release date is delayed because of the service provider not being able to meet the release date. Alternately, if a release were to go-ahead but a service provider didn’t update its systems, this could put parties in breach of the Code (e.g. if they couldn’t follow a new process as the required system was not updated in time for the release date) or create significant additional costs for other participants.
Updates are required to the Performance Assurance Schedule in order for there to be provision in the code to apply Performance Charges in this area.
The recommended approach, which was endorsed by the Performance Assurance Board (PAB) on 21 December 2021, is that Performance Charges be set on the following areas:

1. Service Definition performance - we recommend that the Service Level Agreement (SLA) metric relates to the number of SLAs ‘missed’ against the target set in the service definition. We will exclude any metrics that are subject to specific consideration within Ofgem Price Control or Regulatory Reporting.
2. Change request performance – we recommend that two metrics are put in place to measure and incentivise performance in this area:
a) The timeliness of impact assessment completion. For any impact assessments that are rejected by the Technical Expert Panel (TEP) the time would continue at the point of rejection, avoiding the perverse incentive to create poor quality assessments quickly.
b) The timeliness of changes made against the planned release date. For any changes that need to be rolled back and then rereleased at a later date the clock would continue until the completed change has been made, with the TEP being the arbiter of whether the roll back relates to this change, or another cause.

Further information on each of these metrics and how they would be applied can be found in Attachment A, which also sets out how the charges will be set differently for DCC than for GRDS and ERDS, due to their respective scale and role within the market.

Impacts

Other (please specify in the Additional information box below)
Switching experience, Billing accuracy, Trust and confidence
Other - Service Providers
No details provided
There will be consequential impacts on the Performance Assurance User Guide, which will need to be updated to give guidance to Service Providers on who are subject to Performance Charges.
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
N/A
No details provided
-
Central Switching Service (CSS), CSS Certificate Authority, Switching Operator, Gas Retail Data Service, Electricity Retail Data Service
N/A
Distribution Network Operators, DCC
N/A
No details provided
N/A
No
No details provided

Priority & timing

No
-
The planned implementation date will be the June 2022 release, with charges only applicable after CSS goes live.

Impact assessments will be required to clarify the impacts of the changes on Parties and REC Service Providers. An impact assessment period of 15-20 Working Days has been included to accommodate this. A subsequent consultation period of 10 Working Days will also be required to gather industry views on whether they are supportive of the solutions proposed. The Change Panel will be responsible for approving the change plan when the change is raised. An Authority decision will also be required on the Change Proposal due to the materiality of introducing Performance Charges under the REC.

In consideration of the timescales to progress these changes, the proposed code implementation date is the 30 June 2022 release. A breakdown of the proposed timeline can be found in Attachment B.
There is a dependency on Ofgem for the Authority decision on the Change Proposal, which is due by June 2022. The PAB decision is scheduled for the end of May, which therefore gives a one month turnaround. To mitigate this dependency, early engagement with the Authority will be factored into the Performance Charge workplan.
No details provided
-

Activity

Proposed solution summary changed to As the REC Code Manager, I want to ensure that REC Service Providers achieve their Service Level Agreements (SLAs) defined in REC Service Definitions, so that impacts to the REC Code Manager, REC Parties and othe…
Show more
Implementation Date has been updated to 01 Apr 2023.