Theft Detection Incentive Scheme (TDIS) Reporting Periods

  • 1
    Withdrawn
Step 1 of 1
Withdrawn
Summary
This Change Proposal seeks to alter the Theft Detection Incentive Scheme (TDIS) reporting cycle from annual to a quarterly cycle. This alteration is limited the administration of the scheme and will have no impact on how Suppliers submit their reports.

Latest update and next planned activity

Date of latest update
Latest Update
29/01/2028 - Adoption Window closed. Change withdrawn

Impacts Overview

Impacted REC Parties and Market Participants
Energy Supplier (ES)
Impacted REC Documents
Schedule 1 - Interpretations and Definitions Schedule 7 - Energy Theft Reduction
Priority and rationale
Standard

Solution development

Problem Statement
The current annual TDIS Reporting Cycle does not support the effective cost recovery for Suppliers in year, enable Suppliers to monitor their TDIS performance or enable the Code Manager to flexibly adopt improvements to the scheme.
Proposed solution summary
  1. As an Energy Supplier, I want the ability to effectively monitor my TDIS performance so that I can optimise my theft detection operations.
  2. As the Code Manager, I want the TDIS to continually evolve so that performance against the scheme can be improved.
  3. As RECCo, I want the TDIS to continually evolve to support the Theft Reduction Strategy.
Solution documents
R0163 Draft Legal Text (10.04.2024) 05 Jun 2026 ZIP - 2.31 MB
05 Jun 2026
Documents Library
Change Plan

Responsible Committee decision

Not Started

Start:

09 Apr 2024

Due:

21 Jan 2025

Completion:

Original submission

Change details

Jon Dixon - RECCo
9 Apr 2024

Change details

Theft Detection Incentive Scheme (TDIS) Reporting Periods
Theft of energy significantly increases the cost to bill-paying consumers and poses serious risk to people and property. Gas and Electricity Suppliers have obligation under the standard conditions of their licence to prevent, detect and investigate theft. However, even where theft is detected and proven, there is no certainty that the Supplier will be able to recover any money from the consumer. The Theft Detection Incentive Scheme (TDIS) is therefore intended to offset the costs to suppliers of undertaking such activities.

Under the scheme, each Energy Supplier is allocated a proportion of an overall Theft Target, proportionate to their share of both the domestic and non-domestic sectors of the market in both gas and electricity. Those Energy Suppliers who outperform their competitors will receive an incentive payment, while those who underperform will be net contributors.

While the Theft Targets may be subject to evidence-based revisions, the aggregate targets have in practice not been substantively altered since the scheme was introduced. Feedback received from a number of stakeholders including the Energy Theft Reduction Expert Group and wider REC Parties, for instance through consultation on the Theft Target Methodology, suggest that there is growing concern at both the performance of individual Energy Suppliers, and of the overall efficacy of the scheme in reducing levels of theft.

In November 2023 Ofgem wrote to all Energy Suppliers setting out its initial observations on suppliers’ performance in relation to their licence and code obligations. For instance, Ofgem noted that the overall performance of Energy Suppliers had fallen short of TDIS targets over the past two years, with confirmed thefts being around 40% of the aggregate Theft Target.

There may be a number of factors affecting the achievement against targets, including the appropriateness of the prevailing targets themselves. However, the current design of the scheme including the annual reporting cycle limits the opportunities to make appropriate adjustments.
Both the gas and electricity scheme years have historically run from 1 April to 31 March, apart from a period when the scheme was curtailed owing to COVID-19 restrictions. Any changes to the scheme arrangements have been restricted to apply to future reporting periods only, avoiding the potentially retrospective impact that a mid-year change could have on theft reports submitted early in the reporting period, which could unduly disadvantage suppliers who had undertaken such work and more generally disrupt suppliers’ in-flight plans for the year. However, this annual cycle combined with the fact that the full results of the reporting year can only be undertaken once the subsequent reporting year is already underway suggests that cadence of improvements to the TDIS could be restricted to every two years.

This annual cycle also means that the recovery of costs available through a TDIS credit, or conversely the settlement of liabilities to pay into the scheme, can only occur several months into the financial year following the one in which they were incurred. As these rewards or liabilities are determined by the suppliers’ performance relative to their peers rather than against their indicative target, this impact on cash-flow can be hard to forecast.
The annual reporting cycle is currently specified in Schedule 7 of the REC. This determines the cadence of certain activities such as the setting of Theft Targets, the reconciliation of supplier performance against targets and the settlement of payments into or from the scheme. However, Energy Suppliers submit TDIS reports to the Code Manager on a monthly basis, as further clarified in R0091. This change should therefore be limited to the administration of the scheme rather than having any direct operational impacts upon suppliers.

Moving to a quarterly reporting cycle should:
• Mitigate the cash flow issues associated with the current reconciliation timetable, allowing costs to be at least partially recovered in the financial year in which they were incurred;
• Enable Energy Suppliers to better monitor their own performance as compared to their peers; and,
• Enable incremental improvements to the scheme to be adopted more flexibly, realising benefits sooner.
RECCo consultation letter of 15 January and Code Manager Category 3 consultation C£-0061

Impacts

Electricity, Gas, Domestic Prepayment, Domestic Credit, Microbusiness, Small and Medium Enterprise (SME), Industrial and Commercial (I&C)
Trust and confidence, Safety, Ability to pay
Improving the efficacy of the TDIS should further mitigate energy theft, reducing cost to bill paying consumers and the safety risk
Schedule 1 - Interpretations and Definitions, Schedule 7 - Energy Theft Reduction
If this change proposal is accepted, there may be consequential impacts on some existing or new Category 3 documents. For instance it may be appropriate to revise the Theft Target Methodology and/or for RECCo to publish a schedule for the reconciliation, invoicing and credits payable under the scheme.
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
Energy Suppliers
-
No details provided
Data from TDIS reports is already shared with the CDSP on a monthly basis, in order that confirmed theft can appropriately be reflected in gas settlements. This change will not impact upon those arrangements or any consequential process undertaken pursuant to the UNC.
No
No details provided

Priority & timing

No
-
ARE THERE ANY REQUIRED TIMESCALES FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OR IMPLEMENTATION OF THIS CHANGE PROPOSAL?
(Optional)
This is expected to be a relatively low impact change, insofar as it does not change any of the existing obligations on Parties, it would require only that some of the existing activities are carried out on a quarterly rather than annual basis. Whilst this change may not meet the criteria for urgency, if it could be completed by the June scheduled release, this may allow the April-June 2024/25 period to be reconciled early, and any subsequent revisions to the scheme to be consulted upon and if appropriate adopted earlier than would otherwise be the case.
No
No details provided
-

Activity

Proposed solution summary changed to As an Energy Supplier, I want the ability to effectively monitor my TDIS performance so that I can optimise my theft detection operations.As the Code Manager, I want the TDIS to continually evolve so that perform…
Show more
florentina.monea has been allocated as Lead Analyst.
rosalind.timperley, awaghorn have been allocated as SME.