Prepayment Levelisation
Summary
This Change Proposal seeks to introduce the necessary governance and charging arrangements into the Retail Energy Code, to reconcile the impact on Domestic Energy Suppliers of levelling the cost of standing charges to Domestic Consumers paying by means of a Prepayment Meter with those paying by Direct Debit. This proposal is being raised on a contingent basis pending the decision of the Authority on whether to modify the standard conditions of the Gas and Electricity Supply Licences to levelise standing charges. That decision is expected in January 2024. This Change Proposal is being progressed in anticipation of the reconciliation of levelisation costs being administered by the Retail Energy Code Company.
Latest update and next planned activity
Date of latest update
Latest Update
This change was implemented as part of the the Extraordinary release on 28 March 2024. *This Change Proposal has no impacts on Market-wide Half Hourly Settlement
Impacts Overview
Impacted Consumers
Domestic
Impacted REC Parties and Market Participants
Energy Supplier (ES)
Impacted REC Documents
Schedule 1 - Interpretations and Definitions
Solution development
Problem Statement
Ofgem are working towards and consulting on the design and implementation of a levelisation scheme to align the standing charges of Domestic Consumers who pay through a Prepayment Meter with those who pay via DD. RECCo will be the delivery partner for this scheme, however, the requirements and arrangements for the scheme need to be established in the REC.
Proposed solution summary
- As a Domestic Consumer, I want to be charged the same standing charges regardless of whether I pay by DD or have a Prepayment Meter.
- As an Energy Supplier, I want my obligations regarding data provision to be clear so that I can provide accurate data. As an Energy Supplier, I want there to be a fair reconciliation mechanism calculates, reports, invoices and credits my organisation with the outcome of applying the payment levelisation methodology. As an Energy Supplier, I want the arrangements for the payment mechanism and terms, charging arrangements and invoicing to be clearly set out in the REC, so I can meet my obligations and have confidence in how the scheme operates.
- As RECCo, I want my responsibilities in relation to the development and administration of the levelisation scheme to be clearly set out in the REC so that I can successfully deliver the scheme for the industry. As the REC Code Manager, I want the levelisation scheme arrangements to be clearly set out in the REC, so that I can fulfil my role in administering and assuring the scheme.
Solution documents
05 Jun 2026
05 Jun 2026
05 Jun 2026
Documents Library
05 Jun 2026
Download Authority decision on REC modification proposal R0147 - Prepayment Levelisation 23.02.24
Change Plan
Solution development completed
Completed
Start:
22 Sep 2023Due:
12 Oct 2023Completion:
12 Oct 2023Impact assessment period started
Completed
Start:
12 Oct 2023Due:
13 Oct 2023Completion:
13 Oct 2023Impact assessment completed
Completed
Start:
13 Oct 2023Due:
08 Nov 2023Completion:
08 Nov 2023Preliminary Change Report issued
Completed
Start:
08 Nov 2023Due:
17 Nov 2023Completion:
17 Nov 2023Responsible Committee review of Preliminary Change Report
Completed
Start:
17 Nov 2023Due:
21 Nov 2023Completion:
21 Nov 2023Consultation started
Completed
Start:
21 Nov 2023Due:
22 Nov 2023Completion:
22 Nov 2023Consultation closed
Completed
Start:
22 Nov 2023Due:
13 Dec 2023Completion:
13 Dec 2023Final Change Report issued
Completed
Start:
13 Dec 2023Due:
12 Jan 2024Completion:
11 Jan 2024Responsible Committee decision
Completed
Start:
12 Jan 2024Due:
16 Jan 2024Completion:
16 Jan 2024Authority Determination requested
Completed
Start:
16 Jan 2024Due:
17 Jan 2024Completion:
17 Jan 2024Original submission
Change details
Jon Dixon - RECCo
22 Sep 2023
Change details
PPM Levelisation
British energy suppliers must charge their customers at or below a level determined by Ofgem in accordance with its Default Tariff Cap (DTC) methodology. This is a legislative requirement, set out in the Domestic Gas and Electricity (Tariff Cap) Act 2018.
The DTC methodology is cost-reflective and therefore allows for a number of variables to an energy suppliers cost to serve, including regional variations, tariff type and payment method. This currently means that customers on prepayment meters (PPM) and standard credit (SC) payment methods, who are typically amongst the lowest income, usually paying more than equivalent customers paying by direct debit (DD).
In the March 2023 budget the Chancellor announced that the government would align the tariffs of PPM and DD customers, by making an additional allowance within the Energy Price Guarantee (EPG), effectively providing an additional subsidy to energy suppliers in order that the costs of providing PPMs and associated services are not passed through to those customers. The EPG is currently scheduled to remain in effect until the end of March 2024. The government has tasked Ofgem with developing an enduring approach to removing the ‘PPM premium’.
In April 2023 Ofgem issued a ‘Call for Evidence’ on the process of adjustment of charges between consumers using different payment methods, referred to as ‘levelisation’. This was followed up on 25 August 2023 with an Ofgem consultation: Levelling the cost of standing charges on prepayment meters.
That consultation sets out options for adjusting standing charges for customers on PPM so that that are level with those applicable to other payment methods. The consultation also sets out a number of options for delivering the scheme which will reconcile the costs of the levelisation policy between Domestic Suppliers, mitigating any adverse impacts upon competition between them. One of the options set out in the consultation was delivery through the REC.
On 19 September RECCo received written confirmation that it will be the delivery partner for the levelisation scheme. This this is work to be carried out on a contingent basis in facilitation of the 1 April 2024 delivery data and is without prejudice to any decision that the Authority may make following consideration of response to both the current consultation and the anticipated Statutory Consultation to introduce the requirements of the levelisation scheme into the Gas and Electricity Supply Licences. That Statutory Consultation is expected to be issued November 2023 and a final decision on whether to direct the implementation of licence modification to be taken January 2024.
The DTC methodology is cost-reflective and therefore allows for a number of variables to an energy suppliers cost to serve, including regional variations, tariff type and payment method. This currently means that customers on prepayment meters (PPM) and standard credit (SC) payment methods, who are typically amongst the lowest income, usually paying more than equivalent customers paying by direct debit (DD).
In the March 2023 budget the Chancellor announced that the government would align the tariffs of PPM and DD customers, by making an additional allowance within the Energy Price Guarantee (EPG), effectively providing an additional subsidy to energy suppliers in order that the costs of providing PPMs and associated services are not passed through to those customers. The EPG is currently scheduled to remain in effect until the end of March 2024. The government has tasked Ofgem with developing an enduring approach to removing the ‘PPM premium’.
In April 2023 Ofgem issued a ‘Call for Evidence’ on the process of adjustment of charges between consumers using different payment methods, referred to as ‘levelisation’. This was followed up on 25 August 2023 with an Ofgem consultation: Levelling the cost of standing charges on prepayment meters.
That consultation sets out options for adjusting standing charges for customers on PPM so that that are level with those applicable to other payment methods. The consultation also sets out a number of options for delivering the scheme which will reconcile the costs of the levelisation policy between Domestic Suppliers, mitigating any adverse impacts upon competition between them. One of the options set out in the consultation was delivery through the REC.
On 19 September RECCo received written confirmation that it will be the delivery partner for the levelisation scheme. This this is work to be carried out on a contingent basis in facilitation of the 1 April 2024 delivery data and is without prejudice to any decision that the Authority may make following consideration of response to both the current consultation and the anticipated Statutory Consultation to introduce the requirements of the levelisation scheme into the Gas and Electricity Supply Licences. That Statutory Consultation is expected to be issued November 2023 and a final decision on whether to direct the implementation of licence modification to be taken January 2024.
As set out in the Ofgem consultations, consumers who pay by PPM typically pay more for Standing Charges than consumers who pay by Direct Debit. It notes that Consumer research from the Department for Energy Security & Net Zero from 2022 shows that there are differences in the level of fuel poverty and vulnerability between consumers on different payment methods. Proportionally, the percentage of households that are classed as fuel poor are higher for PPM (and Standard Credit) than those that pay by Direct Debit. However, it also notes that of all households in fuel poverty, a much higher proportion pay by Direct Debit than those paying by PPM (or Standard Credit). The assessment of the impact of any redistribution of cost between such consumer categories is therefore balanced. However, in the event that Ofgem decide to proceed with the levelisation scheme, it is clear that this will become a licence obligation upon Energy Suppliers with effect from 1 April 2024 to coincide with the end of the Energy Price Guarantee.
A change is required to the REC in order to set out:
a) the requirements of RECCo in relation to the development and (subject to final decision) administration of the levelisation scheme;
b) the payment mechanism and terms, charging arrangements and invoicing schedule within the REC;
c) the application of remedies in the event of late payment;
d) the process for Energy Suppliers to follow in the event they wish to query or dispute a calculation of a charge made by RECCo;
e) the role of the Code Manager and or the Performance Assurance Board;
f) the approach to auditing the calculations, payments and charges applicable through the scheme
a) the requirements of RECCo in relation to the development and (subject to final decision) administration of the levelisation scheme;
b) the payment mechanism and terms, charging arrangements and invoicing schedule within the REC;
c) the application of remedies in the event of late payment;
d) the process for Energy Suppliers to follow in the event they wish to query or dispute a calculation of a charge made by RECCo;
e) the role of the Code Manager and or the Performance Assurance Board;
f) the approach to auditing the calculations, payments and charges applicable through the scheme
See:
Ofgem Call for Evidence, April 2023: Levelisation of payment method cost differentials
Ofgem consultation, August 2023: Levelling the cost of standing charges on prepayment meters.
Ofgem Call for Evidence, April 2023: Levelisation of payment method cost differentials
Ofgem consultation, August 2023: Levelling the cost of standing charges on prepayment meters.
Impacts
Electricity, Gas, Domestic Prepayment, Domestic Credit
Billing accuracy, Ability to pay
-
Schedule 1 - Interpretations and Definitions
It is expected that this Change will result in a new Schedule to the REC, new definitions to be inserted into the Interpretation Schedule and possible a new Category 3 document prescribing data submission formats
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
-
No details provided
Whilst changes are not expected to be required to either the EES or the GES for 1 April 2024 delivery, as the levelisation of standing changes is expected to become an enduring aspect of the domestic retail sector, there may be scope to improve the integrity of industry data indicating whether a consumer is utilising PPM payment methods and streamlining associated industry processes, including but not limited to the purposes of informing the future levelisation of charges between consumers, pursuant to this Change.
Energy Suppliers
-
No details provided
This Change Proposal is not expected to have any consequential impacts upon the other industry codes.
No
No details provided
Priority & timing
Yes
This Change Proposal must be implemented no later than 1 April 2024.
Ofgem are currently consulting on Options for the design of the levelisation scheme and these are expected to be set out with a Statutory Consultation on modifications to the Gas and Electricity Supply licence November 2023. Subject to the outcome of that statutory consultation, the licence modifications are expected to come into effect 1 April 2024. From that data Energy Suppliers will be prohibited from applying a higher Standing Charge for PPM consumers than Direct Debit consumers. In the absence of a scheme such as set out in this proposal, that will mean suppliers are unable to recover the full extent of their costs in relation to PPM consumers. As suppliers have different ratios of PPM consumers as compared to Direct Debit consumers within their portfolio, that would have an adverse effect on competition and in the extreme, but mean that suppliers with a high proportion of PPM consumers are unable to fully recover cover their operating costs. Having the PPM levelisation scheme in place alongside the anticipated new licence conditions will ensure that there is a mechanism for the timely and accurate invoicing of suppliers to reconcile the cost of the levelisation policy to maintain cash flows and ensure that no supplier is placed at a competitive disadvantage.
Ofgem are currently consulting on Options for the design of the levelisation scheme and these are expected to be set out with a Statutory Consultation on modifications to the Gas and Electricity Supply licence November 2023. Subject to the outcome of that statutory consultation, the licence modifications are expected to come into effect 1 April 2024. From that data Energy Suppliers will be prohibited from applying a higher Standing Charge for PPM consumers than Direct Debit consumers. In the absence of a scheme such as set out in this proposal, that will mean suppliers are unable to recover the full extent of their costs in relation to PPM consumers. As suppliers have different ratios of PPM consumers as compared to Direct Debit consumers within their portfolio, that would have an adverse effect on competition and in the extreme, but mean that suppliers with a high proportion of PPM consumers are unable to fully recover cover their operating costs. Having the PPM levelisation scheme in place alongside the anticipated new licence conditions will ensure that there is a mechanism for the timely and accurate invoicing of suppliers to reconcile the cost of the levelisation policy to maintain cash flows and ensure that no supplier is placed at a competitive disadvantage.
As above, implementation of the change must be effective no later than 1 April 2024. RECCo will work with Energy Suppliers to ensure that the design build and test phase of the change meets there needs as far as practicable within those data parameters.
Whilst the Change Proposal is not of itself dependent upon the progress of the Statutory Consultation, RECCo consider that it would be beneficial to ensure that the change is fully developed in time to inform any additional complementary references that may suitable be placed in the draft licence modification, and to enable Energy Suppliers to view and respond to both sets of drafting as part of parallel consultations.
No details provided
-